golftuber.

Callaway · Irons

Callaway X Forged Max

3 reviewers

The takeaway

Not as forgiving as the name suggests.

They agree

  • +Holds carry on mishits
  • +Faster, lower-spinning than the standard
  • +Compact for a forgiving forging

The knocks

  • Visible cavity looks out of place
  • Extra offset, not truly forgiving

Buy it ifyou want forged feel with some mishit help

Skip it ifyou want real game-improvement forgiveness

Check price on AmazonPGA Tour SuperstoreWe may earn a commission from retailer links. It never changes the scores.

The verdicts.

2nd Swing Golf

Master fitters, Trackman-heavy testing

Loved it

variation in carry is only 5 yards for five shots

A forgiving single-piece forging that held carry distance remarkably well on mishits while keeping a compact players look.

+ the facts · 4 pros · 2 cons
  • +Only 5 yards of carry variation across five shots with varied strike locations
  • +Faster ball speed and roughly 400-600 rpm lower spin than the standard X Forged
  • +Soft forged feel with genuine forgiveness despite being a single-piece forging
  • Spin fluctuated noticeably on poor strikes
  • Lower launch and spin than the standard model if you need stopping power

For: Players who want forged muscle-back feel but need forgiveness and distance retention on mishits

Full reviewWatch the review

Club Champion (TXG)

Tour-level fitting studio

Liked it

I wouldn't want to see this in the whole set personally

More forgiving and faster than the standard X-Forged and it performed better than the reviewer expected, but the wider sole, visible back and added offset put him off the look for a full set.

+ the facts · 5 pros · 3 cons
  • +More ball speed and a little more carry than the standard X-Forged
  • +Held 197 yards on a badly struck shot
  • +Not a hollow body, so no clunky high-face feel and none of the hot-spot inconsistency
  • Reviewer disliked the look, you can see the back of the head at address
  • Noticeably more offset, pushes his shots left
  • Lower peak height and lower spin means it won't stick greens as well

For: Mid to high handicappers, or as the long-iron end of a blended X-Forged set

Head-to-headWatch the review

MyGolfSpy

Data-driven independent testing

Lukewarm

I'm just not sure where the market who the market is

The supposedly more forgiving X Forged, and the one product in the release the hosts openly struggle with. It is still single piece forged and still unforgiving, and the visible cavity structure looks out of place on a players iron.

+ the facts · 1 pros · 4 cons
  • +Extends the reach of the single piece forged X Forged slightly
  • Not actually all that forgiving despite the Max name
  • Visible cavity structure hanging at address looks out of place
  • Odd longer, shallower shaping and out-of-place X styling

For: Hard to say, and that is the hosts' problem with it